Understanding Liability Risks for HOA Board Members

Serving on a homeowners association (HOA) board is an important way to give back to your community–but it also carries serious responsibilities. The board of directors are often surprised to learn that their volunteer roles can come with personal legal risk. What happens if a disgruntled homeowner sues the board? Can individual board members be held liable and have legal action taken against them for a decision gone wrong?

Ultimately, the answer isn’t a simple yes or no. While many legal protections exist for those board of directors members who act ethically and in good faith, liability can arise when decisions fall outside legal or fiduciary boundaries.

In this guide, we’ll walk through the legal landscape HOA board members must navigate, highlight common legal risks, explain the legal protections in place, and show how a professional HOA management Company in Charlotte, Huntersville NC, Wilmington NC, Myrtle Beach SC, and Fort Mill SC, like Kuester Management Group, can help board of director members stay protected while leading effectively.

Can HOA Board Members Be Personally Held Liable?

Yes, but only under specific circumstances.

Generally, HOA board members are shielded from personal liability if they follow their association’s governing documents, act within the scope of their authority, and avoid making bad faith decisions.

This protection is grounded in a legal doctrine known as the Business Judgment Rule, which gives board members legal breathing room to do their jobs without the constant threat of being sued over every difficult decision.

But this protection isn’t limitless. Board members who abuse their power, violate fiduciary duties, or act negligently can indeed face legal consequences.

Real Liability Risks: When Board Members Can Be Sued

While most board members won’t find themselves in court, it’s important to understand the kinds of conduct that can trigger personal liability.

1. Breach of Fiduciary Duty

Each board member has a legal obligation to act in the best interest of the HOA. That includes:

• Making prudent financial decisions.
• Avoiding conflicts of interest.
• Enforcing rules consistently.

For example, if a board member hires a family member’s landscaping company without disclosing the relationship or comparing bids, that could be viewed as self-dealing, and a violation of fiduciary duty.

2. Selective Enforcement or Discrimination

If the board penalizes some residents for violations but ignores the same behavior in others, especially when discrimination is suspected, legal claims can arise. Even unintentional bias can create liability. Boards must enforce rules uniformly and avoid making decisions that could be perceived as discriminatory.

3. Negligence in Maintenance Duties

Let’s say a resident trips and falls in a poorly lit community walkway. If the board knew the lighting was out and failed to act, it could be considered negligent. Failure to properly maintain common areas, especially when safety is involved, can lead to costly lawsuits.

4. Fraud and Misrepresentation

Misleading homeowners about assessments, financials, or board decisions can expose individual directors to legal action. Transparency is not just best practice, it’s a legal necessity.

5. Conflicts of Interest

Failing to disclose personal or financial interests in board decisions can quickly erode trust and open the door to legal scrutiny. Even the appearance of a conflict can lead to problems.

How Board Members Are Protected

Thankfully, most boards are composed of honest, responsible individuals who want to do right by their neighbors. Several legal and structural protections help shield these volunteers from personal liability:

The Business Judgment Rule

As long as a board member acts in good faith, with reasonable care, and in the best interest of the association, courts generally won’t interfere–even if the outcome of a decision turns out poorly.

Indemnification by the HOA

Most governing documents include indemnification clauses, which commit the association to covering legal expenses if a board member is sued for actions taken while serving the community. However, this protection usually doesn’t apply if the board member acted outside their authority or violated the law.

Directors and Officers (D&O) Insurance

D&O insurance coverage is a critical safeguard. It protects individual board members from personal financial loss related to lawsuits against the board. Kuester Management Group helps ensure every client association maintains proper D&O coverage tailored to its risk level and state regulations.

How to Avoid Liability as an HOA Board Member

Board members aren’t expected to be legal experts, but they are expected to lead responsibly. Here’s how to minimize risk:

1. Understand and Follow the Governing Documents

Every board decision should align with the association’s bylaws, CC&Rs, and state statutes. If you’re unsure, consult with your HOA management partner or legal counsel before acting.

2. Keep Decisions Transparent and Documented

Good meeting minutes are your first line of defense. Clearly document board votes, reasoning, and dissent when applicable. Avoid informal decision-making that skips records.

3. Treat All Homeowners Equally

Consistency is king. Enforce rules fairly and avoid favoritism, especially when dealing with violations or fines. A pattern of uneven treatment is a common basis for legal claims.

4. Disclose Conflicts of Interest Immediately

If a decision involves someone close to you–or might be seen that way–disclose it and recuse yourself from the vote. Transparency builds trust and shields you from liability.

5. Work With a Professional HOA Management Company

Partnering with a firm like Kuester Management Group ensures boards have access to experienced governance support, legal insight, and operational oversight. We help board members stay focused on serving their communities–not dodging legal threats.

How Kuester Management Group Reduces HOA Board Risk

Board service should feel empowering, not intimidating. That’s why Kuester works closely with HOA boards to reduce the risk of missteps, and ensure community decisions are made on solid legal and operational ground.

Here’s how we help:

• Governance and Legal Compliance
  We guide boards through complex bylaws, CC&Rs, and state laws, so you can make decisions with confidence.
• Financial Integrity
  Our financial systems ensure transparent, audit-ready accounting. That includes fair collections, accurate budgeting, and detailed financial reporting.
• Insurance Management
  Kuester helps boards assess their insurance needs and maintain up-to-date D&O insurance coverage to protect directors from personal risk.
• Dispute Prevention and Resolution
  We help resolve resident disputes and prevent escalation by implementing clear processes and fair enforcement practices.
• Education and Training
  Our team provides orientation for new board members and ongoing training on fiduciary responsibility, ethics, and leadership best practices.

Whether you’re a new volunteer or a veteran board president, working with a professional HOA management company helps you lead confidently, avoid missteps, and protect yourself from unnecessary liability.

HOA Leadership Without Fear

Volunteering for your HOA board should be a source of pride, not a cause for legal anxiety. While there are risks involved, they’re manageable with the right knowledge, protections, and partners in place.

By following your governing documents, making fair and well-documented decisions, and working with a trusted management company like Kuester, you can fulfill your role as a board member confidently, and safeguard your personal and financial well-being along the way.

For more information or for help with your HOA, reach out to the Kuester team today.

FAQs