Can You Refuse to Join a Homeowners Association?

In the United States, the Foundation for Community Association Research says that nearly 74 million people live in communities that are governed by Homeowners Associations (HOAs). Furthermore, this number has steadily risen over the past couple of decades.

HOAs often promise orderly neighborhoods, well-maintained amenities, and higher property values. However, they do come with fees, strict rules, and potential restrictions that can be a source of contention for many residents.

So, what happens if you’re not interested in joining an HOA even while you’re interested in purchasing a piece of real estate within a residential community? Is there any way you can refuse to join the HOA?

This is an important question, and it highlights how key it is to consult with a professional management company. For example, Kuester Management Group is pleased to be a leading provider of HOA management near Charlotte NC, Huntersville NC, Wilmington NC, Myrtle Beach SC, and Fort Mill SC.

In this article, we will answer some common questions many homeowners and real estate investors have about the enforcement of rules in an HOA and whether or not such membership aligns with one’s lifestyle choices.

Understanding HOAs and Their Role

HOAs are organizations established to manage and maintain community standards, ensuring that shared spaces, such as fitness centers or a neighborhood pool, are upheld and aligned with certain benchmarks.

Typically governed by a board of directors, HOAs enforce rules outlined in covenant documents, known as the Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs).

The board’s responsibilities often involve maintaining landscaping, managing community amenities like pools or clubhouses, and handling repairs for shared areas like private roads or sidewalks.

The Two Types of HOAs

• Mandatory HOA: In this type of HOA, membership is package deal and automatically required when you purchase a home within the association’s jurisdiction. These HOAs collect monthly payments in the form of dues and enforce rules. Dues payments can range from modest sums to special assessments or other annual fees.
• Voluntary HOA: This is an association where membership is voluntary and allows homeowners to choose whether to join and participate in the association’s services or initiatives. However, there could be restrictions placed on homeowners who choose not to join and access to certain community amenities may be prohibited.

Living in an HOA has its advantages, such as access to well-maintained amenities, increased property values, and a sense of community. However, it does come with some drawbacks, including strict regulations, potential fines for violations, and sometimes costly dues.

Understanding the role of an HOA is crucial for homeowners to weigh the benefits and obligations of living under its governance.

Can You Legally Refuse to Join an HOA?

• Scenario #1: When HOA membership is mandatory. In most cases, if you purchase a property in a community governed by an HOA, membership is part of the real estate deal. This is often outlined in the CC&Rs, which are legal documents that bind property owners to the HOA’s rules. These documents are usually recorded with the county and are considered part of the property deed. Therefore, when you invest in a home within an HOA-governed community, you are agreeing to abide by its rules and pay its fees. Refusing to join isn’t an option–you are automatically a member. If you attempt to avoid participation, you may face legal implications, including fines or a lien on your property.
• Scenario #2: Some communities have voluntary HOAs, where homeowners can either opt in or opt out. In these cases, the HOA typically provides optional benefits such as community events, landscaping services, or access to fitness centers or tennis courts. Opting out of membership means you won’t be subject to fees or restrictions but may miss out of the perks of the neighborhood. While you won’t face penalties for not joining, there could be social or practical challenges, such as reduced influence in community decisions or even fewer opportunities to interact with your neighbors.

Key Legal Considerations

State laws and court precedents can impact whether you are required to join an HOA. Some states uphold the mandatory nature of HOAs, while others may have provisions that allow you to challenge or opt out of membership under specific circumstances, such as national origin, sexual orientation, or some other living experience.

Refusing to join an HOA in a mandatory community can result in significant financial and legal ramifications, even foreclosure, as the HOA has the authority to enforce its rules and collect payment of fees.

What if You Buy Property Outside an HOA?

For those who wish to avoid the restrictions and fees associated with HOAs, buying property in a non-HOA community is an attractive option.

These properties are not subject to the rules and regulations enforced by an HOA, offering more freedom and flexibility in how you use your property.

However, it’s essential to confirm that the property you’re interested in is truly outside of an HOA’s jurisdiction before making a purchase.

Below are key points to consider.

How to Confirm No HOA Obligations:

• Check property listings for HOA mentions or restrictions.
• Review the property’s title or deed for any CC&Rs.
• Contact the local county or city office to inquire about HOA oversight.
• Request a disclosure from the seller confirming the absence of an HOA.

Pros of Living Outside an HOA:

• Greater autonomy over property uses and modifications without needing the approval from an HOA. For instance, if you want to paint your house bright orange or raise chickens in your backyard, you’re welcome to.
• No HOA fees or dues to pay, potentially reducing additional expenses.
• Fewer rules and restrictions on property upkeep, building codes, and other individual choices.

Cons of Living Outside an HOA:

• Lack of communal maintenance, which could lead to property value decline or neighborhood disarray.
• Potential for unregulated neighbor behaviors that could affect the community’s overall atmosphere. If there is no overarching community law, there may be more disputes or arguments.
• Limited or no access to amenities, which are typically provided by HOAs, such as neighborhood pools, fitness centers, and clubhouses.

Tips for Dealing with HOAs

If you’re already living in a community that is overseen by an HOA or are considering purchasing a property within one, it’s important to approach interactions with the HOA thoughtfully. Here are some tips for navigating HOA relationships.

• Negotiate or Resolve Disputes Amicably: Open, respectful communication is key. If disagreements arise, try to address them directly with the board of directors or property management company. Many conflicts can be resolved through clear dialogue or mediation without escalating to legal action.
• Review HOA Documents Thoroughly Before Buying: Before buying a home or condo, carefully read the CC&Rs, Articles of Incorporation, and other governing documents. Understanding the rules, fees, and restrictions beforehand helps avoid surprises and stress later on–and it confirms you’re comfortable with the community’s guidelines.
• Seek Legal Advice When in Doubt: If you’re uncertain about your rights or responsibilities within the HOA, consult a real estate attorney. Legal counsel can help interpret complex documents, address concerns about HOA rules, and assist with conflicts.

Seek Assistance from an HOA Management Company

Deciding whether to join an HOA can truly impact many aspects of homeownership, so it’s important to understand the pros and cons for your own peace of mind.

Before making any decisions, research the property, get a full idea of your obligations, and see if these things align with personal preferences.

Additionally, it’s wise for HOAs to partner with a professional management company. With questions about how your HOA can create a community that is appealing to existing and potential homeowners, reach out to Kuester Management Group directly.

FAQs